Rain Stories

by Emet/Ari L. Monts, Faculty Fellow

אָמַר רַבִּי יוֹחָנָן: שְׁלֹשָׁה מַפְתְּחוֹת בְּיָדוֹ שֶׁל הַקָּדוֹשׁ בָּרוּךְ הוּא שֶׁלֹּא נִמְסְרוּ בְּיַד שָׁלִיחַ, וְאֵלּוּ הֵן: מַפְתֵּחַ שֶׁל גְּשָׁמִים, מַפְתֵּחַ שֶׁל חַיָּה, וּמַפְתֵּחַ שֶׁל תְּחִיַּית הַמֵּתִים.

Rabbi Yochanan said that hKbH holds 3 keys they are not transmitted to Their agent, and they are: the key of rain, the key of life, and the key of reviving the dead. (Taanit 2a)

One of the few acceptable ways to regularly talk about Gd in the secular public is to talk about the weather. “Wow, it’s getting cooler,” I say each October, as if I haven’t lived in a four-season climate my entire life. There’s something uniquely divine about the fact that each day the sun rises and sets when we think it should, that the seasons change, that the rain comes. For the most part, many of us live in safe, protected homes. Except in the cases of ever-increasing crises, weather does not feel urgent, and yet it is still a wonder. A moment of noticing, of looking up.

The Rabbis of the Talmud were also fascinated by the weather. Which makes sense — our ancestors were much more dependent on land in ways that could be felt. Rain in its season meant food on tables and, when it didn’t come, or came at the wrong time, it could be catastrophic. The rain was also a matter of moral inquiry for the Rabbis. In inheriting a theological tradition rooted in the give and take of Deuteronomy, for the Rabbis, stories about rain were also stories about the validity of the brit, or the unique covenant with YHVH. 

“If,” Deuteronomy writes, and the Rabbis included as part of the daily Shema, “you obey my commandments….I will give rain for your land in its proper season.” In the rabbinic mind, if the rain does not come, then there is a moral failure to address. In the tractate on fasting, Taanit, much of the conversation about communal fasts centers around the rain cycles. The first chapter of the misha sets up that if the community made it to the 17th of Cheshvan with no rain, the halakhah is to “בְעִי רַחֲמֵי” — to ask for mercy, often through decreed fasts and often through direct exhortation to the divine. 

My chevruta Natalie and I just finished a small series of these narratives in chapter 3 of Taanit. Much of the gemara in the chapter is a response to the mishna about Choni, the circle maker, a pre-rabbinic figure who through words and actions could make the rain come. These stories, like the coming and going of weather patterns, are confusing when read together. They enact what Julia Watts Belser calls aggadic dialectic: “a literary form that allows the Bavli to voice unsettled questions about its own religious assertions and articulate a self-critical ethical and theological voice.” Just as the stories use the Rabbi as a pious figure whose closeness with Gd can bring about miracles, they also remind us that reliance on miracle alone is not the rabbinic project.

On Taanit 24b, a story is transmitted:

There was a man who was sentenced to lashing by the bet din of Rava because he had sexual relations with a gentile woman. Rava lashed the man, and he died. 

This thing was heard of in the house of Shabur, the Sassynian King. He wanted to vex Rava. His mother Ifra Hormiz said  to her, “Don’t be mixed up with this affair, for all the Jews ask for is given to them by their master!” He said to her, “What’s this?” [She replied] “They ask for mercy and the rain comes!” He said to her, “The rain comes because it’s time for the rain to come. Rather, let them ask for mercy now, in the middle of the summer and would the rain come?” 

Ifra Hormiz sent for Rava: “Direct your mind, and ask for mercy that the rain will come!” He asked for mercy and the rain did not come. Rava said before Gd, “Ribono shel olam, master of the universe! ‘Elokim, with our ears we heard our ancestors stories to us of the work you did in their days, in the days of old.’ And we, with our eyes do not see?!” 

The rain came until it poured out from the gutters of Tzipora into the Tigris. 

[Later,] Rava’s father appeared to him in a dream. He said to him, “Who is there doing all this begging before Gd?” He said [further] to him, “Change your place.” Rava changed his place. The next day, he found his bed was full of knife marks.

Talk about twists and turns and aggadic dialectic! We are handed a story of divine intervention while being left to question whether or how Rava influenced the intervention. When we finished learning this, I found myself curious about whether or not Rava is the hero in this story. He killed a man and brought on a flood, and yet the ghost of his father seems to save him. What’s the point of this story?

The whole thing is weird, but I especially find Rava’s appeal to Gd worth exploring. After he asks for mercy the first time, mainly to appease Ifra Hormiz, a powerful gentile woman, nothing happens. So, he does what rabbis do, he hooks his plea on his interpretation of Torah. The original poetry of the Psalms that he’s quotes when he calls out hinges on the special relationship between Gd and Israel in order to appeal to Gd’s mercy. Rava reinterprets this to call on the special relationship to look good in front of a representative of a powerful empire. 

I think what’s going on in this story, and what’s going on whenever we talk to one another about the weather is a negotiation between human agency and the divine project. What we do — whether it is sacrifice in the temple, asking for mercy, or changing a line in our daily prayers — influences the Divine. We play a role in the ongoing creation of the world. And while our revelations may come through interpretations and re-interpretations of Torah, it is not a text separated from the material world around us. If we are to use it, it should not be to exact justice in such a fervent manner that a man dies, but to make us more compassionate, more merciful, just like the Gd we are emulating. 

The story that immediately follows this specific Rava tale bolsters this idea, first introduced to me through Ruth Calderon’s children’s book, A Rainy Day Story. In it, Rabbi Chanina ben Dosa is walking on the road when it begins to rain. He cries out, “Ribono shel olam, master of the universe! All the world is in comfort, and Chanina is suffering?!” The rain stops. But when Chanina is at home (and Rashi adds, after some time has passed) Chanina realizes it hasn’t rained since he asked for it to stop. He cries out again, “Ribono shel olam! All the world is suffering and Chanina is in comfort?!” The rain returns.

The rabbinic project works best when we appeal to the divine in ways that benefit as many of us as possible. Whether that appeal is through our Torah study or calling out to HaShem, we should behave as if we will be heard. We may not make it rain, but we play a role in what happens to the world around us. 

Read More